Introduction
Investors are increasingly curious about how Bitcoin behaves relative to traditional asset classes like stocks, bonds, and commodities. While past performance doesn’t guarantee future results, historical data provides valuable insights into Bitcoin’s volatility, risk profile, and correlation with other investments.
This analysis explores:
- Bitcoin’s all-or-nothing performance compared to equities, bonds, and commodities.
- Rolling correlations between Bitcoin and the S&P 500 Index.
- Bitcoin’s role during market stress periods (e.g., 2022 inflation surge, 2023 banking crisis).
- Why Bitcoin is not a hedge for equities but offers low-correlation diversification.
Bitcoin’s Performance: Top or Bottom, Never in Between
The Calendar Year Returns Quilt
From 2012 to 2023, Bitcoin displayed extreme performance relative to eight major asset classes (S&P 500, gold, U.S. Treasuries, etc.):
- Top performer in 9 of 12 years, often outpacing equities by wide margins.
Example: In 2013, Bitcoin surged 5,428%, while the Russell 2000 (second place) gained just 38.8%. - Bottom performer in 3 years (2014, 2018, 2022), with steep losses like -73.8% in 2018.
- Equity-like behavior: Bitcoin’s returns aligned with risk-on assets, not safe havens like Treasuries.
Key Takeaway:
Bitcoin acts as a high-risk, high-reward asset, resembling equities more than bonds or commodities.
Correlation: Bitcoin’s Evolving Relationship with the S&P 500
Understanding Correlation Coefficients
- +1.0: Perfect lockstep movement.
- 0.0: No observable relationship.
- -1.0: Opposite directions.
Bitcoin vs. S&P 500: A Low-Correlation Dance
- 50-day rolling correlation (2012–2024) fluctuated between -0.4 and +0.5, averaging near 0.1.
- Diversification potential: Low correlation suggests Bitcoin may reduce portfolio volatility when combined with equities.
👉 Explore Bitcoin investment strategies
Stress Tests: Bitcoin During Market Crises
2022 Inflation Surge
- Stocks and bonds fell—a rare event. Bitcoin dropped -64.3%, underperforming the S&P 500 (-18.1%).
- Correlation briefly spiked during the FTX collapse, but remained low on average (~0.1).
2023 Banking Crisis
- Bitcoin rose 20.5% in March 2023, while the S&P 500 gained 5%.
- Correlation declined further, reinforcing Bitcoin’s divergence from traditional markets.
Key Takeaway:
Bitcoin’s decentralized nature may appeal during systemic financial stress, but it’s not a consistent hedge.
FAQs
Q: Is Bitcoin a good hedge against stock market downturns?
A: No. Bitcoin’s correlation with the S&P 500 is unstable, and it often falls during equity sell-offs (e.g., 2022).
Q: Why does Bitcoin have low correlation with equities?
A: It trades as a speculative asset driven by crypto-specific factors (adoption, regulation) rather than corporate earnings.
Q: Should I include Bitcoin in a diversified portfolio?
A: Potentially—its low correlation can reduce overall risk, but its extreme volatility requires careful allocation.
Conclusion: Bitcoin’s Role in Modern Portfolios
While Bitcoin isn’t a hedge for stocks, its low correlation with the S&P 500 and unique risk/return profile make it intriguing for diversification. As traditional hedges like Treasuries lose effectiveness (see rising stock-bond correlation), Bitcoin’s role may evolve.
👉 Learn more about crypto asset allocation
Final Notes:
- Bitcoin is speculative: Prices can swing wildly.
- Past trends ≠ future results: Monitor correlation shifts.
- Due diligence is critical: Understand risks before investing.
Sources: Bloomberg, WisdomTree Research. Data as of March 2024.